Skip to content
Economy Media Stay Informed Anytime, Anywhere
Tech

Senate Panel Advances Trump FCC Pick as Democrats Boycott Vote

Republicans on the Senate Commerce Committee advanced Danielle Thumann Severs to the FCC after Democrats skipped the vote, putting a 3-1 GOP majority within reach.

West front of the United States Capitol in Washington, D.C.
Image: US Government / Architect of the Capitol

The Senate Commerce Committee on Wednesday advanced President Donald Trump’s nominee to the Federal Communications Commission, Danielle Thumann Severs, after every Democrat on the panel stayed away from the vote. If the full Senate confirms her, Republicans would hold a 3-1 majority at the agency that regulates broadcasters, telecom carriers and broadband providers.

The vote came at a committee meeting called by Sen. Ted Cruz, the Texas Republican who chairs the panel. Democrats had asked him to pull the nomination and wait until the new Congress convenes in January, when they will control the Senate. Cruz refused, and the committee’s Republicans approved the nomination on their own, according to TV Tech, a trade publication that covers the broadcast industry.

What happened

Thumann Severs is senior counsel to Brendan Carr, the FCC chairman. Newsweek reported that she previously served as a legal adviser in Carr’s office and worked in government affairs at Crown Castle, a company that owns cell towers and fiber networks, before returning to the commission. Her portfolio has covered broadband, public safety, infrastructure and consumer affairs. She would fill the Republican seat left open by former Commissioner Nathan Simington, according to The Desk, a media-industry news site.

At Wednesday’s meeting, Cruz rejected the Democrats’ argument that a Republican nominee should be paired with a Democratic one. He said the president is not required to nominate in pairs and that the committee has considered FCC nominees separately in the past. “The law merely says that no more than three of the commissioners may be from the same party,” Cruz said, according to TV Tech.

Sen. Bernie Moreno, an Ohio Republican on the committee, called the Democrats’ absence a “total disgrace,” TV Tech reported.

Why Democrats stayed away

In a letter dated Nov. 16, all Democratic members of the committee, led by ranking member Sen. Maria Cantwell of Washington, asked Cruz to drop Thumann Severs from the agenda. According to Newsweek, they wrote that there was “no mandate for the outgoing majority to rush through a partisan FCC nomination in its final weeks.”

The Democrats argued that any Republican nominee should move together with the renomination of Anna Gomez, the commission’s only Democrat, and with a Democratic pick for the empty seat once held by former Commissioner Geoffrey Starks. They also turned Cruz’s own words against him, citing a 2014 statement in which he said controversial nominees should not be confirmed during a lame-duck session, the period between an election and the start of a new Congress. A spokesperson for Cruz, Blair Taylor, told Newsweek the committee looked forward to advancing the nomination and suggested Democrats take up the open seat with the White House.

Cantwell said Democrats object to what she described as the majority “stacking independent commissions with Republicans,” TV Tech reported.

Questions about Thumann Severs’ testimony added to the dispute. Sen. Ben Ray Luján, a New Mexico Democrat, asked the committee to hold another hearing. Newsweek reported that Luján cited internal FCC emails, obtained through public records requests, that he said show she was involved in the review of the Paramount-Skydance merger. He argued that conflicts with her hearing testimony that she had not worked with Carr on media matters. TV Tech said Luján pointed to records gathered by Protect Democracy, a nonprofit watchdog group, which he said showed her testimony was false. As of Newsweek’s report, neither the FCC nor Thumann Severs had publicly responded to the allegations.

Why it matters

The FCC normally has five commissioners, and federal law allows no more than three to come from the same party. The commission currently has Carr and Commissioner Olivia Trusty on the Republican side and Gomez as the lone Democrat. A third Republican would give Carr a firmer working majority on media ownership, broadband and spectrum decisions.

The vote also reflects a broader fight over how Carr has used the FCC’s power over broadcasters. At Thumann Severs’ Nov. 10 confirmation hearing, Cruz, who has criticized Carr’s pressure on networks in the past, asked how she would handle broadcast license transfers. The Desk reported that she pledged to follow precedent and existing law. Cruz said at the hearing that “the First Amendment places important limits on the government’s ability to regulate speech.”

Outside groups have weighed in as well. Jessica J. González of Free Press Action, a media advocacy group, urged senators to vote against the nomination and said Cruz had “rammed through” the vote, according to TV Tech.

What comes next

The nomination now goes to the full Senate, where Republicans hold the majority until January. Gomez’s term expired over the summer, but under FCC rules she can keep serving until she is renominated or replaced, The Desk reported. Trump is not required to nominate a Democrat to that seat, though he cannot exceed the three-member limit for any one party. Whether Senate leaders schedule a floor vote before the lame-duck session ends will decide whether the 3-1 majority takes shape this year.