Shoppers Push Back on Pricier Polyester as Clothing Costs Climb
Apparel prices have hit records since the pandemic, and shoppers are increasingly rejecting cheap synthetic fabrics sold at premium prices.
American shoppers are paying more for clothes than they did before the pandemic, and more of them are deciding the garments are not worth it. CNBC reported Friday that rising apparel prices, combined with a long shift toward cheaper synthetic fabrics such as polyester and nylon, have left many consumers checking labels and avoiding low-quality materials sold at premium prices. Survey data from AlixPartners, a global consulting firm, points the same way, and some retailers built around natural fibers appear to be benefiting.
What is happening
For roughly two decades before the pandemic, clothing prices in the U.S. generally fell, according to the consumer price index. Since 2020 that trend has reversed, and apparel prices have climbed to record highs, CNBC reported. Supply chain disruption came first. Tariffs followed, and then the war with Iran, which pushed up oil prices. Oil matters here because petroleum is the raw material for many synthetic fibers.
At the same time, the makeup of the clothing Americans buy has changed. In 2010, about 60% of apparel imported into the U.S. was mostly cotton, according to CNBC. That share has fallen to around 45%, and garments made mainly from synthetic fibers now account for most imports. The shift has been driven by fast fashion, the boom in athleisure and changes in where clothes are made. Euromonitor, a market research company, found that U.S. sports apparel grew at a 4.9% rate from 2015 to 2025, compared with 2.6% for apparel and footwear overall, CNBC noted.
Synthetic clothing is still cheaper to import. Data from the U.S. Commerce Department’s Office of Textiles and Apparel, cited by CNBC, show that from January to August 2026 the average unit price of imported apparel made mostly of synthetic fibers was $2.64 per square meter, compared with $3.67 for largely cotton garments. Since 2010, import costs for synthetic apparel have risen about 11%, while cotton apparel costs have climbed 21%.
Why shoppers are pushing back
AlixPartners’ 2026 Consumer Sentiment Index, which surveyed more than 9,000 U.S. consumers in July, found that 86% of respondents believe price and quality must line up, and 88% consider transparent pricing important, FashionUnited, a fashion trade publication, reported. The firm’s own analysis found that average advertised full prices for women’s apparel rose 15% over the two years through August 2026.
Sonia Lapinsky, who leads the fashion practice at AlixPartners, told CNBC that brands selling synthetic materials as if they were something better are “becoming very low on consumers’ minds.” Janine Stichter, a consumer analyst at the investment bank BTIG, said the industry’s move toward cheaper materials had gone “too far,” and that quality has mattered much more to shoppers over the last three or four years than in the decade or two before.
The survey also hinted at a reshuffling among retailers popular with younger shoppers. In AlixPartners’ ranking of brand sentiment for young adult specialty retailers, ultra-fast-fashion seller Shein and Spanish chain Zara each fell three places, to fifth and seventh, according to CNBC. Zara’s sales and profits have nonetheless kept growing. Shein, which passed higher tariff costs on to customers in 2025 and later blamed slower sales on those prices, did not respond to CNBC’s request for comment.
Who is benefiting
Companies built around natural fibers have gained ground. About 90% of Ralph Lauren’s apparel is made mainly from cotton, leather, wool, viscose, cashmere or silk, according to the company’s 2026 sustainability report. CNBC reported that the fashion house sold more goods at full price and cut back on markdowns in fiscal 2026, and its shares have risen about 85% over the past two years.
Quince, a direct-to-consumer brand that sells cashmere, silk and other natural-material goods at relatively low prices, reached a valuation of about $10 billion this year. Resale platform ThredUp’s 2025 report also ranked Quince third for best resale value, a jump of 16 places.
What comes next
Analysts say the shift may not mean consumers are spending more overall. Aneesha Sherman, a senior retail analyst at Bernstein Research, told CNBC that some shoppers are likely trading down on quality as prices rise. Sheng Lu, a professor of fashion and apparel studies at the University of Delaware, noted that many synthetic-heavy brands mainly serve value and mass-market customers. For retailers, the risk is in the margins: Stichter warned that cheaper products that have to be marked down can end up earning less than higher-quality goods sold at full price. With the holiday season under way, how shoppers weigh price against quality will be closely watched across the industry.


